Mark Atwood (fallenpegasus) wrote,
Mark Atwood
fallenpegasus

The Memory Hole

While playing around with Amazon today, I found a book review I wrote back in 2002.

The review was for I, Weapon.

And I utterly savaged it. My review was


Everything that was bad with New Wave SF

This is a dire piece of drek. It combines everything that was bad about the New Wave, made the sex and violence both utterly gratuitious and utterly uninteresting, and makes blunders about biology, physics, and computers on nearly every page.
But what's worse is that it's not a novel. It is, instead, a writer's bible for what could be a novel. The structure alternates between chapter long exposatory dumps, and chapter long meetings between talking heads where they give each other "As you know, Bob" style exposatory lumps.

Avoid.



But the funny thing is, I don't have any memory at all of reading this book, or of posting this review. I must have utterly flushed it down the memory hole.
Subscribe

  • Mark Atwood speaking at Ignite OSCON 2010

    Mark Atwood speaking at Ignite OSCON 2010 Originally uploaded by O'Reilly Conferences This entry was originally posted at…

  • At LCA2010

    Wellington, January 2010, originally uploaded by datacharmer. Giuseppe caught me when I looked focused and concerned about something. I have…

  • At the Drizzle Developers Conference

    The Drizzle Developers, hard at work DSC_0129, originally uploaded by krow. The Drizzle Developers, hard at work, thinking about Burning…

  • Post a new comment

    Error

    Comments allowed for friends only

    Anonymous comments are disabled in this journal

    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    Your IP address will be recorded 

  • 1 comment