?

Log in

No account? Create an account
entries friends calendar profile My Website Previous Previous Next Next
Mark Atwood
fallenpegasus
fallenpegasus
"Dangerous Visions"
Last night I finished reading the, ahem, "celebrated" Dangerous Visions. I could do up a story by story critique, or even better, a retrospective of the successes, failures, insights, and many many abject idiocies of "New Wave SF" as presented in this text, but they've all already been done. New Wave is now so old and so dated that people have published critiques of the critiques of the critiques of the era (which is something, oddly, that would make sense to the people portrayed in the "future" of New Wave, but would likely not made sense to most SF readers when this anthology was first published.)

However, I will make one observation. The young Harlan Ellison needed to learn to STFU. His forwards to each story exhibit severe logorrhea. I could have redpenned them down by a quarter without substantual changes, and cut them by half again without losing the points he was making.
2 comments or Leave a comment
Comments
From: ptomblin_lj Date: January 10th, 2005 10:03 pm (UTC) (Link)
When I was a kid I tried to read every sci fi I could get my hands on. Somebody said "Oh, you have to read Michael Moorecock (?), HE'S THE NEXT BIG THING". I read it, and it sucked. And then I encountered Dangerous Visions, I read it, and it sucked. Then I encountered "Again Dangerous Visions", and it sucked more. I guess I'll stick with the last big thing, thanks.
intrepid_reason From: intrepid_reason Date: January 10th, 2005 10:14 pm (UTC) (Link)
LMAO, I find your comment so amusing, because one of the reviews for the book praises his forwards as being "the true key to this compliation." I am so amused.
2 comments or Leave a comment