Home
December 2009   01 02 03 04 05 06 07 08 09 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31

Responding to Dvorak on the gPhone. Summary: he's an idiot

Posted on 2007.11.12 at 12:58
Current Location: Home, Capitol Hill, Seattle WA
Tags: , , ,
John Dvorak is an idiot. Old and privilaged and cantankerous, but still doubly an idiot.

The very use case that he ridicules, using a smartphone/PDA to look up location, hours, directions, etc of a restaurant, instead of actaully calling up the restaurant, is one that I see "normal" people, not just geeks, do all the time.

People don't want to wait on hold, nav a voicemail tree, or even talk to a rushed overworked human. They want to glance at the knowledge they want, and have it right at that moment.

And that's what ubiquitous `net, currently via usable phone-based browsers, gets you, that realtime telephony, POTS or cell, doesn't.

Comments:


Speedy Alkahest
[info]bolstrood at 2007-11-12 21:42 (UTC) (Link)

Dvorak

Dvorak is a professional troll, by his own admission. He's the journalistic equivalent of Fred Phelps.

If Slashdot ever stopped linking to his stuff he'd probably have to start working for a living.

Speedy Alkahest
[info]bolstrood at 2007-11-12 21:43 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Dvorak

chris neitzert
[info]ckn at 2007-11-12 21:48 (UTC) (Link)

Re: Dvorak

couldn't have expressed these sentiments better myself
chris neitzert
[info]ckn at 2007-11-12 21:49 (UTC) (Link)

resturants answer their phones?

every single restaurant I've called in the past year have had a machine answer the phone, and that machine was not capable of receiving, let alone answering, complicated questions like 'what part of town is that in?' or 'what are the nearest cross streets?'.

Dvorak needs to retire.
古崇賢, aka Brother Claymore of Perpetual Peace
[info]dcseain at 2007-11-12 21:53 (UTC) (Link)

You're spot-on

I already do Google searches from my mobile all the time. Unless i need reservations, i'd rather know where it is than talk to them.
gipsieee
[info]gipsieee at 2007-11-12 22:12 (UTC) (Link)
May I suggest, that even your "normal" sample is self-selected to a higher socio-economic class than average.
May I also suggest that looking up information about a restaurant on the restaurant's site (for example hours or menu options) only works if they have a web presence. Google would suffice if you already had their address and simply needed directions, but nav systems do that well already. I suppose there is some gain in not needing more than one widget, but...

That said, I am, of course, currently in rural Virginia. I find restaurants by looking in the yellow pages and paying attention as I drive through town. The web is NOT the most effective tool to find food in this town.
And it's only marginally better in Baltimore and DC.
Mauser
[info]mauser at 2007-11-13 02:06 (UTC) (Link)
It also presumes the website is up to date, rather than some Geocities template they set up 10 years ago and haven't touched since.

The brew shop I deal with has a web page, but the store hours aren't on it, so I had to call. Fortunately they were on the answering machine. Unfortunately I'd just missed them.
Erratica
[info]roseembolism at 2007-11-13 05:35 (UTC) (Link)
I don't see using Google and similar functions as all that different from using the phone book, with the added benefit that if I'm already in the car I don't need to hunt up a gas station.

My Razor for example isn't all that expensive or capable, and can easily connect to smart yellow pages, google maps, or review sites. I don't think it's so much a matter of socioeconomic status, as of being young or technologically hip enough to prefer modern technology.
awfief
[info]awfief at 2007-11-13 12:52 (UTC) (Link)
EXACTLY. I like to use the phone just because often the website is wrong, or doesn't have exactly what I want (ie, are they open on a Sunday? are they still taking orders right now?), but I'll use the web to find the phone number!
Lisha
[info]lishablog at 2007-11-13 09:28 (UTC) (Link)
I wonder how many other people are like me in having become more comfortable NOT trying to get information out of a person if I can get it out of another source. Not only do I not call stores or restaurants or banks unless I absolutely have to, I rarely call my friends or associates until I've sms'd them first to see if now is a good time. I don't like uncomfortable telephone conversations. (I LOVE good telephone conversations. That's different.)

Getting on the phone to get information or make a reservation means waiting on hold, possibly getting rude or snarky service, possibly not hearing or being heard if, say, I'm out on the street at a bus stop where I've gotten off a bus and suddenly realize that I'm completely lost...

If I can get information myself, quickly, from a website on my phone, that's fantastic. I can read faster than I can navigate a telephone menu. I can understand a map faster than I can figure out where I am and where my goal is via spoken or written directions (in most cases). And if I happen to be in a country where they speak a language that isn't the most comfortable for me, I didn't have to stumble through in pidgin and then hope I know what was said to me.

memegardener
[info]memegarden at 2007-11-14 06:11 (UTC) (Link)
This is exactly why in Japan you can buy *anything* from a vending machine. It's quicker to stick money/card in and push buttons than to go through the communication rituals with a human.
captain_button
[info]captain_button at 2007-11-14 13:55 (UTC) (Link)
I don't text message people*, but I agree with you about not calling or talking to people for stuff that can be readily obtained without doing so. It is usually easier, more effective, and faster. Plus you know you aren't annoying the people answering the phone or the meatspace customers waiting on them.

(Plus things like when I check on the progress of a mail order shipment a dozen times a day. If I was calling a person to check on that, I'd be a real jerk. As it is, I'm just wasting bandwidth and my time.

* Assuming that is what sms means, which tells you something about me right there.
Previous Entry  Next Entry